PIA (Pakistan International Airlines) Privatization: Is The 135 Billion Rupee Bid Shockingly Low?

A National Icon Changes Hands Amid Controversy

On December 23, 2025, Pakistan made headlines when a consortium led by Arif Habib secured a 75% stake in Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) for 135 billion rupees—roughly $482 million USD. For many, this marked a long-overdue reform, shedding a loss-making national carrier that had drained billions from public coffers. But for others, including veteran journalist Matiullah Jan, the deal raised red flags.

Matiullah Jan pointed out that PIA’s recent bid of 135 billion rupees, approximately $482 million, is strikingly low compared to the cost of its fleet. With around 32 aircraft in operation—including several Boeing 777s—and a single new Boeing 777 historically valued at over $400 million, critics argue the winning offer doesn’t even cover the price of one flagship plane. Such claims have sparked heated debate: Is this privatization a smart economic move or a fire sale of national assets?

Understanding the PIA Privatization Structure

To grasp why opinions are divided on the 135 billion rupee bid, we first need to understand what was actually sold.

PIA’s privatization wasn’t a straightforward asset dump. The government restructured the airline by splitting it into two entities:

PIA Holding Company: This absorbed most of the legacy debts—estimated at over 600-800 billion rupees—and non-core assets like the Roosevelt Hotel in New York.
PIA Core (PIACL): This is the operational airline sold in the auction, including the fleet, routes, slots, brand, and workforce, with a much cleaner balance sheet.

The winning Arif Habib consortium bid 135 billion rupees for 75% control. Under the terms:

Only 7.5% of the bid (about 10 billion rupees) goes to the government as cash.
The remaining 92.5% must be reinvested directly into revitalizing PIA.
The government retains a 25% stake initially, with options for future sale.

This structure exceeded the reserve price of 100 billion rupees and came after competitive bidding against groups like Lucky Cement. It was televised for transparency—a rarity in such deals.

From global experience the privatizations, this setup is common: Governments offload liabilities to make the entity attractive, prioritizing revival over immediate cash. But it also fuels criticism when headline numbers seem low compared to tangible assets like aircraft.

PIA’s Fleet: The Crown Jewels of the Airline

At the heart of the undervaluation debate is PIA’s fleet—one of Pakistan’s most valuable aviation assets.

As of late 2025, PIA operates approximately 32 aircraft:

Boeing 777 variants: Around 8-10 wide-body jets (777-200ER, 777-300ER) for long-haul routes.
Airbus A320 family: About 16 narrow-body planes for domestic and regional flights.
ATR 42/72: A handful for shorter routes.

These aren’t scrap metal. Boeing 777s, even used, hold significant market value. New list prices exceed $400 million per unit, but PIA’s older models (average age over 15 years) trade on the secondary market for $50-100 million each, depending on condition, engines, and maintenance records.

Conservative estimates put the total fleet value in the hundreds of millions USD—potentially rivaling or exceeding the $482 million bid when combined with landing slots, bilateral rights, and the PIA brand. Add priceless intangibles like trained crew and historical routes to Europe (recently reopened after bans were lifted), and it’s easy to see why some view 135 billion rupees as a bargain.

Real-world insight: In aviation deals I’ve analyzed, fleet value often drives bids, but operational realities—like high fuel costs, competition from Gulf carriers, and past safety issues—drag valuations down.

Why Critics Like Matiullah Jan Say the Bid Undervalues PIA’s Assets

Matiullah Jan, a respected Pakistani journalist known for probing economic stories, has been vocal. He highlights that such offers undervalue the airline’s actual assets and raise concerns about the bidding process.

His core argument: Compare the bid to just one Boeing 777. Even accounting for age, these planes represent massive capital. Social media amplified this, with some posts (erroneously claiming $48 million instead of $482 million) suggesting the entire airline sold for less than one aircraft.

Broader concerns include:

Limited bidders: Only three consortia qualified, raising questions about competition.
Reinvestment clause: Most money stays in PIA rather than public coffers—great for revival, but feels like a sweetheart deal.
Hidden value: International routes and slots could be worth billions over time.

Beginners might think privatization means “selling everything cheap,” but advanced observers note these deals often prioritize strategic buyers who can turn around loss-makers. Still, Jan’s point stings: When debts are stripped out, shouldn’t the clean asset fetch more?

Common mistake: Comparing to new aircraft prices. Avoid this—used plane values plummet like cars after a few years.

The Case for Why 135 Billion Rupees Might Be a Fair Deal

Not everyone sees undervaluation. Defenders, including government officials and economists, argue the bid reflects harsh realities.

PIA was bleeding money—accumulating hundreds of billions in losses over a decade due to mismanagement, overstaffing, and political interference. The debt transfer was essential; without it, no sane bidder would touch PIA.

Key counterpoints:

Market context: Used wide-bodies like 777s fetch $50-100 million today amid oversupply post-COVID.
Total value to Pakistan: Debt relief saves taxpayers billions long-term; reinvestment ensures survival.
Exceeded expectations: From a failed 2024 attempt with low offers to this competitive auction.

Practical tip from experience: In emerging markets, privatization success isn’t just the price—it’s stopping the hemorrhage. PIA’s revival could boost tourism, jobs, and competition in air travel.

Humor break: Imagine selling a vintage car with a blown engine—you fix the engine first (debt transfer), then buyers bid higher. Without that, you’d get scrap value.

Implications for Pakistan’s Aviation and Economy

This deal could reshape air travel in Pakistan. A privatized PIA might modernize fleet, improve service, and compete with Emirates or Flydubai. Seasonal peaks (Hajj, summer travel) could thrive with better management.

For investors: Aviation remains risky—fuel volatility, geopolitics—but a lean PIA has upside.

Advanced insight: Watch for fleet upgrades; the consortium pledged further investment.

FAQs

What was the exact winning bid for PIA privatization? The Arif Habib-led consortium bid 135 billion Pakistani rupees (about $482 million USD) for a 75% stake on December 23, 2025.
Is PIA’s Boeing 777 really worth over $400 million? New ones yes, but PIA’s used models are valued at $50-100 million each on the secondary market.
Why do critics say the 135 billion rupee bid is too low? They compare it to fleet assets, arguing even one Boeing 777 exceeds the perceived value, especially after debts were removed.
How much cash does the government actually get? About 10 billion rupees (7.5% of the bid); the rest must be reinvested in PIA.
What happens to PIA’s debts after privatization? The government absorbed most legacy liabilities into a separate holding company.
Will PIA flights improve under new ownership? Potentially yes—private management often brings efficiency, but it depends on execution.
Who is Matiullah Jan and why does his opinion matter? A senior Pakistani journalist known for investigative reporting on economic and governance issues.
Is this the end of PIA as a national airline? No—the government retains 25% initially, and the brand continues under new control.

Conclusion: Balancing Reform and Asset Value in PIA’s Future

PIA’s 135 billion rupee privatization bid has ignited debate, with critics like Matiullah Jan rightly questioning if it fully captures the airline’s fleet and asset value. Yet the deal’s structure—debt relief, reinvestment mandates, and competitive bidding—suggests a pragmatic step toward sustainability.

As Pakistan navigates economic reforms, this transaction reinforces a hard truth: Turning around iconic but troubled institutions requires tough choices. Whether this bid proves undervalued or visionary will unfold in the skies ahead. One thing’s certain: PIA’s story is far from over.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and based on publicly available reports as of December 25, 2025. Values and details may evolve.

External Sources